【问题标题】:Trouble getting tests to run properly无法让测试正常运行
【发布时间】:2015-11-24 17:50:56
【问题描述】:

我已经尝试了两天来测试一个模拟电梯的程序,但收效甚微。这是我的电梯课程,该程序仍在进行中,我还注释掉了一些对我遇到问题的测试可能不是必需的方法。如果您认为需要,我很乐意展示更多代码

class Elevator
  attr_accessor :current_floor

  GROUND = 0
  TOP = 15

  def initialize
    @floors = []                  # list of floors to travel to
    @pending = []                 # store floors not in direction of travel
    @current_floor = GROUND
    @going_up = true              # cannot travel downward from ground floor
    @going_down = false
  end

  def get_input
    gets.chomp
  end

  def run
    enter_floors
    sort_floors
    move_to_floor
  end

  def enter_floors
    # prompts the user for input and calls check_floor_numbers
  end

  def check_floor_numbers floors
    # calls validate_floors to ensure user entered '2' instead of 'two'
    # if proper floor numbers have been entered this method adds the number
    # to @floors array other wise it calls floor_error_message
  end

  def floor_error_message
    puts "Please enter numbers only."
    enter_floors
  end

  def sort_floors
    # if we are on the ground floor this method sorts @floors in ascending order
    # if we are on the top floor it sorts @floors in descending order
    # else it calls check_direction_of_travel
  end

  def move_to_floor
    floor = @floors[0]

    if @current_floor == floor
      puts "You are already on floor #{floor}"
    else
      print_direction
      (@current_floor..floor).each { |floor| puts "...#{floor}" }
      @current_floor = floor            # update current_floor
      @floors.delete_at(0)              # remove floor from list
    end

    check_for_more_passengers
  end

  def check_for_more_passengers
    puts "Are there any more passengers? (Y/N)"
    answer = (get_input).upcase

    answer == 'Y' ? run : check_next_move
  end

  def check_next_move
    if @floors.empty? && @pending.empty?
      end_ride
    else
      move_to_floor
    end
  end

  def check_direction_of_travel
    # not implemented - add floor to appropriate array depending on dir
    # of travel
  end

  def end_ride
    puts "\n\nEND."
  end

  def print_direction
    msg = " "
    @going_up ? msg = "Going Up!" : msg = "Going Down!"
    puts msg
  end
end

我正在尝试测试电梯是否可以移动到特定楼层。起初,我在不运行程序本身的情况下测试来自控制台的输入时遇到了麻烦。我asked a question about this 并被推荐给this answer in a different question。有问题的答案将gets.chomp 提取到一个单独的方法,然后覆盖测试中的方法。我最终得到了这样的结果:

  describe "it can move to a floor" do
    before do
        @@moves = ["2", "N"]
        def get_input; @@moves.next end
    end

    it "should move to floor 2" do
      e = Elevator.new
      e.run
      assert_equal(e.current_floor, 2)
    end
  end

问题: get_input 未被正确覆盖,运行测试套件提示用户输入,因此建议我 open the Elevator class in the test itself 以确保该方法被正确覆盖。尝试这样做最终导致了这样的测试:

  describe "it can move to a floor" do
    before do
      class Elevator
        attr_accessor :current_floor
        @@moves = ["2", "N"]
        def get_input; @@moves.next end
        def run; end
      end
    end

    it "should move to floor 2" do
      e = Elevator.new
      e.run
      assert_equal(e.current_floor, 2)
    end
  end

我不得不覆盖 run 并为 current_floor 添加一个 attr_accessor,因为我遇到了方法缺失错误。

问题:此测试出现以下错误:

1) 失败:它可以移动到一个楼层#test_0001_should move to floor 2 [elevator_test.rb:24]:预期:无实际:2

我尝试尽可能地整理 Elevator 类,并在给定程序参数的情况下使方法尽可能简单。

谁能指出我解决这个问题的正确方向,也许是伪代码示例(如果可能的话)来演示如果答案是重构,我应该如何解决这个问题。

请记住,我还想实施其他测试,例如检查电梯类是否可以维护楼层列表,或者它是否可以改变方向,当您将来回答时。

【问题讨论】:

  • @floors 是一个空数组,您的代码使用 @floors[0] 恰好为 nil。如上所示您的代码给出错误ArgumentError: bad value for range
  • 电梯课对我来说运行良好。你想让我把整个未注释的类放到 github 上吗?
  • 如果你没问题,你可以分享它 - 并在上面的问题中放置一个链接。
  • gist.github.com/sheekap/730088ddef85511dbd3e(@floors 在 check_floor_number 方法中填充)

标签: ruby minitest


【解决方案1】:

您的测试类ElevatorTest 正在重新定义Elevator 以覆盖方法get_input,但它没有打开elevator.rb 中定义的类Elevator,而是创建了一个新类@987654326 @ 恰好在 ElevatorTest 类中定义。记住每个类也是一个模块,所以现在你有一个新类ElevatorTest::Elevator

为了解决这个问题,我对elevator_test.rb 进行了一些更改,如下所示。

gem 'minitest', '>= 5.0.0'
require 'minitest/spec'
require 'minitest/autorun'
require_relative 'elevator'

class Elevator
    @@moves = ["2", "N"].each
    def get_input; @@moves.next end
end

class ElevatorTest < MiniTest::Test
  def test_working
    assert_equal(1, 1)
  end

  describe "it can move to a floor" do
    before do
    end

    it "should move to floor 2" do
      e = Elevator.new
      e.run
      assert_equal(e.current_floor, 2)
    end
  end
end

另外,请记住在定义@@moves 时使用.each - 它返回一个枚举器。我们只能在枚举器上调用.next

【讨论】:

  • 谢谢!这种解释很有帮助,现在测试通过了:)
猜你喜欢
  • 2013-12-24
  • 2016-03-03
  • 1970-01-01
  • 1970-01-01
  • 2019-09-06
  • 1970-01-01
  • 2019-01-30
  • 1970-01-01
  • 2011-11-14
相关资源
最近更新 更多