【问题标题】:Conditional Sum in mySQL?mySQL中的条件总和?
【发布时间】:2011-07-26 07:33:30
【问题描述】:

我不太擅长 SQL,所以我一直在尝试通过 PHP 来处理这个问题并进行非常基本的 mySQL 查询,但显然我一直在用完内存(在 PHP 中),因为我处理了很多数据(并做大量可怕的嵌套foreach)。我希望有一种方法可以重新编写我的 SQL 以防止这种情况发生。

这是我正在处理的表格(仅显示相关字段):

组织

  • 组织 ID

资金周期

  • 循环ID
  • NonUnityCut​​BackAmount
  • UnityCut​​BackAmount

行政请求

  • 循环ID
  • 组织 ID
  • 申请金额
  • 资助金额
  • 每次关闭

资金请求

  • 循环ID
  • 组织 ID
  • 申请金额
  • 资助金额
  • 每次关闭

事件请求

  • 循环ID
  • 组织 ID
  • 申请金额
  • 资助金额
  • 每次关闭
  • UnityReq

所以,这里是复杂的部分。我需要为AmountRequestedAmountFunded 的每个组织创建总和(虽然不确定跨多个表求和,但这两个似乎相当容易),以及来自所有请求表中的请求的计算字段AmountAfterCutbackAdministrativeRequestsCapitalRequestsEventRequests)。

AmountAfterCutback 等于:AmountFunded - (AmountFunded * Cutback)。

如果削减只是一个值,那可能就足够简单了。但是,Cutback 来自FundingCycles 表。所以我不能直接求和并应用削减,我必须找出每个请求的削减,为此我必须查看每个请求,然后通过其CycleID 检查并查看削减的内容该请求在FundingCycles 表中。

默认情况下,Cutback 将等于 NonUnityCutBack。但是,如果请求是Unity 请求(仅限EventRequestsUnityReq == 1),则缩减等于UnityCutBack。然而,它变得更具挑战性,因为削减可以单独应用于每个请求,覆盖统一或非统一削减(如果PerOff is > 0)。

因此,我必须以某种方式汇总组织提出的每个请求,并正确计算上述字段。我将在下面展示我的解决方案,我会警告它绝对不是很漂亮,而且此时甚至无法正常工作,因为它在尝试通过 PHP 处理它时内存不足。我知道必须有更好的方法来做到这一点。某种方法可以对每个请求进行条件计算,以便可以在查询中求和,而不是我下面笨拙的 PHP 解决方案?有任何想法吗?感谢任何有耐心读到这里的人,我知道这是一个问题的 PITA。非常感谢任何帮助!

function calculate_public_records()
{
      $total_req_total = 0;
      $total_funded_total = 0;
      $total_cutback_total = 0;

      $organizations = array();

      foreach($this->organizations as $org)
      {
          $id = $org['OrgID'];
          $org_req_total = 0;
          $org_funded_total = 0;
          $org_cutback_total = 0;

          $cycles = array();

          foreach($this->cycles as $cycle)
          {
                $cycle_req_total = 0;
                $cycle_funded_total = 0;
                $cycle_cutback_total = 0;

                $cycle_requests = array();

                foreach($this->request_types as $type)
                {
                    $reqs = $this->funding_request_model->getRequests($type, $cycle['CycleID'], $id);
                    foreach($reqs as $r)
                    {
                        $cutback = $cycle['NonUnityCutBack'];
                        if ($type == "Event") $cutback = ($r->UnityReq == 1) ? $cycle['UnityCutBack'] : $cutback;
                        $cutback = ($r->PerOff != 0) ? $r->PerOff : $cutback;

                        $request = array();
                        $request['id']        = $r->ReqID;
                        $request['type']      = $type;
                        $request['name']      = $r->Title;
                        $request['requested'] = number_format($r->RequestTotal, 2);
                        $request['funded']    = number_format($r->AmtFunded, 2);
                        $request['cutback']   = number_format(($r->AmtFunded - ($r->AmtFunded * $cutback)), 2);

                        $cycle_req_total += $request['requested'];
                        $cycle_funded_total += $request['funded'];
                        $cycle_cutback_total += $request['cutback'];

                        $cycle_requests[] = $request;
                    }

                }

                $cycle_totals = array();
                $cycle_totals['requested'] = number_format($cycle_req_total, 2);
                $cycle_totals['funded'] = number_format($cycle_funded_total, 2);
                $cycle_totals['cutback'] = number_format($cycle_cutback_total, 2);

                $org_req_total += $cycle_req_total;
                $org_funded_total += $cycle_funded_total;
                $org_cutback_total += $cycle_cutback_total;

                $cycles[] = array('name' => $cycle['CycleName'], 'requests' => $cycle_requests, 'totals' => $cycle_totals);
          }

          $org_totals = array();
          $org_totals['requested'] = number_format($org_req_total, 2);
          $org_totals['funded'] = number_format($org_funded_total, 2);
          $org_totals['cutback'] = number_format($org_cutback_total, 2);

          $total_req_total += $org_req_total;
          $total_funded_total += $org_funded_total;
          $total_cutback_total += $org_cutback_total;

          $organizations[] = array('id' => $org['OrgID'], 'name' => $org['Organization'], 'cycles' => $cycles, 'totals' => $org_totals);
      }

      $totals = array();
      $totals['requested'] = number_format($total_req_total, 2);
      $totals['funded'] = number_format($total_funded_total, 2);
      $totals['cutback'] = number_format($total_cutback_total, 2);

      return array('organizations' => $organizations, 'totals' => $totals);

计算总结:

# For tables AdministrativeRequests, CapitalRequests & EventRequests, calculate:

    SUM(AmountRequested)
    SUM(AmountFunded)

# For tables AdministrativeRequests, CapitalRequests & EventRequests, calculate:

    AmountAfterCutback = AmountFunded - (AmountFunded * Cutback)

# Cutback calculation pseudocode

if( <table>.PerOff > 0 ) {
    Cutback = <table>.PerOff
} elseif ( <table> == EventRequests && EventRequests.UnityReq == 1 ) {
    Cutback = FundingCycles.UnityCutBack
} else {
    Cutback = FundingCycles.NonUnityCutBack
}

【问题讨论】:

  • 我们在这里讨论的数据集有多大?
  • 你真的应该花时间学习 SQL。这并不难 - 你永远不应该做你的数据库可以为你做的事情。
  • 澄清(伪),AmountRequested, AmountFunded = SUM(*Requests.Amount*)AmountAfterCutback = AmountFunded - (AmountFunded * IF(UnityReq, FundingCycles.UnityCutBackAmount, FundingCycles.NonUnityCutBackAmount)。但是,如果 PerOff 不为零,是否应用它而不是任何其他缩减或使用?
  • 我添加了我认为需要进行的计算的摘要。这可能会使其他人不必工作。请根据需要检查和更新。
  • 尚未查看所有答案,但我稍微更新了计算伪代码。获取 SUM(AmountRequested) 和 SUM(AmountFunded) 不是由表 Organizations 获取的,它适用于所有请求表(AdministrativeRequests、CapitalRequests、EventRequests)。

标签: php mysql codeigniter


【解决方案1】:

这是我的尝试 - 更新为使用 UNION ALL 而不是 UNION

SELECT OrgID,
       SUM(AmountRequested),
       SUM(AmountFunded),
       SUM(AmountFunded - (
           AmountFunded * 
           IF( PerOff > 0,
               PerOff,
               IF( UnityReq = 1,
                   UnityCutBackAmount,
                   NonUnityCutBackAmount
               )
           )
       )) AS AmountAfterCutback
  FROM (
SELECT o.OrgID,
       ar.AmountRequested,
       ar.AmountFunded,
       ar.PerOff,
       null AS UnityReq,
       fc_ar.CycleID,
       fc_ar.NonUnityCutBackAmount,
       fc_ar.UnityCutBackAmount
  FROM Organizations o
  JOIN AdministrativeRequests ar
    ON ar.OrgID = o.OrgID
  JOIN FundingCycles fc_ar
    ON fc_ar.CycleID = ar.CycleID
 UNION ALL
SELECT o.OrgID,
       cr.AmountRequested,
       cr.AmountFunded,
       cr.PerOff,
       null AS UnityReq,
       fc_cr.CycleID,
       fc_cr.NonUnityCutBackAmount,
       fc_cr.UnityCutBackAmount
  FROM Organizations o
  JOIN CapitalRequests cr
    ON cr.OrgID = o.OrgID
  JOIN FundingCycles fc_cr
    ON fc_cr.CycleID = cr.CycleID
 UNION ALL
SELECT o.OrgID,
       er.AmountRequested,
       er.AmountFunded,
       er.PerOff,
       er.UnityReq,
       fc_er.CycleID,
       fc_er.NonUnityCutBackAmount,
       fc_er.UnityCutBackAmount
  FROM Organizations o
  JOIN EventRequests er
    ON er.OrgID = o.OrgID
  JOIN FundingCycles fc_er
    ON fc_er.CycleID = er.CycleID
) tmp
 GROUP BY OrgID;

【讨论】:

  • 所以,我认为这种方法效果很好,但我遇到了一个有趣的问题。事实证明,如果有两个请求具有相同的 AmountRequested、相同的 CycleID、相同的 OrgID,则查询会忽略其中一个。关于如何解决这个问题的任何想法?
  • @David Savage:是的,抱歉 - 将 UNION 更改为 UNION ALL。 UNION 删除重复的行。我应该已经发现了。
  • 太棒了,解决了它。感谢您的所有帮助,在弄清楚您编写的查询的过程中,我学到了很多 SQL :)
【解决方案2】:

学习 SQL。快速阅读表明答案可能类似于...

    SELECT orgid
    , SUM(requested) AS amountrequested
    , SUM(funded) AS amountfunded
    , SUM(IF(unityreq=1, unitycutback, nonunitycutback) * funded) 
           AS amountaftercutback
    FROM
    ( 
      SELECT cycleid, orgid, unityreq, 
        SUM(amountrequested) as requested, SUM(amountfunded) as funded
      FROM
        (
           (
           SELECT cycleid, orgid, AmountRequested, AmountFunded, 0 as unityreq
           FROM administrativerequests 
           )
           UNION
           (
           SELECT cycleid, orgid, AmountRequested, AmountFunded, 0 as unityreq
           FROM capitalrequests
           )
           UNION
           (
           SELECT cycleid, orgid, AmountRequested, AmountFunded, unityreq
           FROM eventrequests
           )
        ) ilv
      GROUP BY cycleid, orgid, unityreq
    ) ilv,
    fundingcycles fc
    WHERE fc.cycleid=ilv.cycleid
    GROUP BY orgid

【讨论】:

  • 不过,不要认为您的答案包括PerOff。我猜测ilv 中的另一个字段以及基于它的另一层嵌套IF()
  • +1 我喜欢在外部选择上加入 FundingCycles 一次的想法。
  • 我回过头来将此查询重新用于使用 PerOff,但我仍然遇到与 Mike 相同的问题。如果同一组织在同一周期内有相同金额的请求,则忽略总和中的一个请求。有解决此问题的方法吗?
  • @David Savage:根据我对模型的理解,这个查询不会出现你描述的场景。我建议您重新检查您的数据/使用小数据集来识别问题。这可能是允许 peroff 值的更改的结果(我在上面的答案中忽略了)
猜你喜欢
  • 1970-01-01
  • 2022-06-15
  • 2021-03-18
  • 2018-05-14
  • 2021-03-24
  • 1970-01-01
  • 1970-01-01
  • 2021-11-05
  • 1970-01-01
相关资源
最近更新 更多