为什么我的状态机抛出错误：无效转换？

Question

我正在尝试实现状态机。这种情况是，如果提交了文件，则将其发送以供审核，然后获得批准。

但它会抛出一个错误，即已审核 -> 批准转换无效。

这是可能提供更好图片的代码。

为什么会抛出错误？我确保一切都井井有条，但仍然正常。

 public enum ProcessState
    {    
        Submitted,    
        Reviewed,    
        Approved    
    }  

    public enum Command
    {    
        Submit,    
        Review,    
        Approve    
    }   

    public class Process
    {    
        class StateTransition
        {
            readonly ProcessState CurrentState;    
            readonly Command Command;      

            public StateTransition(ProcessState currentState, Command command)
            {    
                CurrentState = currentState;    
                Command = command;    
            }   

            public override int GetHashCode()
            {    
                return 17 + 31 * CurrentState.GetHashCode() + 31 * Command.GetHashCode();    
            }    

            public override bool Equals(object obj)
            {    
                StateTransition other = obj as StateTransition;    
                return other != null && this.CurrentState == other.CurrentState && this.Command == other.Command;    
            }    
        }    

        Dictionary<StateTransition, ProcessState> transitions;

        public ProcessState CurrentState { get; private set; }   

        public Process()
        {    
            CurrentState = ProcessState.Submitted;    
            transitions = new Dictionary<StateTransition, ProcessState>    
            {    
                 { new StateTransition(ProcessState.Submitted, Command.Review), ProcessState.Reviewed },

            { new StateTransition(ProcessState.Reviewed, Command.Approve), ProcessState.Approved },

            };    
        }   

        public ProcessState GetNext(Command command)
        {    
            StateTransition transition = new StateTransition(CurrentState, command);    
            ProcessState nextState;

            if (!transitions.TryGetValue(transition, out nextState))

                throw new Exception("Invalid transition: " + CurrentState + " -> " + command);

            return nextState;    
        }    

        public ProcessState MoveNext(Command command)
        {    
            CurrentState = GetNext(command);    
            return CurrentState;    
        }    
    }    

    public class Program
    {   
        static void Main(string[] args)
        {    
            Process p = new Process();

            Console.WriteLine("Current State = " + p.CurrentState);    
            Console.WriteLine("Command.Submit: Current State = " + p.MoveNext(Command.Submit));    
            Console.WriteLine("Command.Review: Current State = " + p.MoveNext(Command.Review));    
            Console.WriteLine("Command.Approve: Current State = " + p.MoveNext(Command.Approve));    
            Console.ReadLine();  
        }    
    }

更新：

这里是错误部分：

  public ProcessState GetNext(Command command)
        {

            StateTransition transition = new StateTransition(CurrentState, command);

            ProcessState nextState;

            if (!transitions.TryGetValue(transition, out nextState))

                throw new Exception("Invalid transition: " + CurrentState + " -> " + command);

            return nextState;

        }

Answer 1

这允许您的示例Main 正确运行。问题是您的transitions 字典没有Command.Approve 的条目。

public Process()
{
    CurrentState = ProcessState.Submitted;
    transitions = new Dictionary<StateTransition, ProcessState>
    {
        //This does nothing.  Submitted -> Submitted
        { new StateTransition(ProcessState.Submitted, Command.Submit), ProcessState.Submitted },
        //Submitted -> Reviewed
        { new StateTransition(ProcessState.Submitted, Command.Review), ProcessState.Reviewed },
        //Reviewed -> Submitted.  Do you want this?
        { new StateTransition(ProcessState.Reviewed, Command.Submit), ProcessState.Submitted },
        //I added this.  Reviewed -> Approved
        { new StateTransition(ProcessState.Reviewed, Command.Approve), ProcessState.Approved }
    };
}

输出：

Command.Submit：当前状态 = 已提交

Command.Review：当前状态 = 已审核

Command.Approve：当前状态 = 已批准

请注意，我没有检查您的所有状态机转换。我只是添加了缺少的一个。