【问题标题】:CASE Statement causing execute time to sky rocketCASE 语句导致执行时间飙升
【发布时间】:2021-09-24 11:12:17
【问题描述】:

我在两个不同的数据库中工作。在创建报告(使用 TSQL)以在部门之间共享时,要求有一个字段来显示来自主数据库的信息(保存在学院数据库中的信息)也已输入到第二个数据库(特定部门使用用于与联邦计划的信息通信)。如果不使用 case 语句检查第二个数据库,则查询其余信息只需不到一秒的时间。使用 case 语句(在其中创建 CTE 以进行检查),它已经运行了 15 分钟,并且在我手动结束执行之前还没有完成。以下是代码(CASE 语句目前已注释掉):

With POWERFAIDS_CHECK as
        (
        Select distinct NAME_MASTER.ID_NUM, 
                (CAST (NAME_MASTER.ID_NUM as VARCHAR) + CAST (EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AID_ELEMENT as VARCHAR) ) as CHECK_ID
        
            From NAME_MASTER
            JOIN EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS on NAME_MASTER.ID_NUM = EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.ID_NUM
            JOIN SCHOLARSHIP on EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AID_ELEMENT = SCHOLARSHIP.AID_ELEMENT
            JOIN PF_FUND_CDE_MSTR on EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AID_ELEMENT = PF_FUND_CDE_MSTR.RPT_CATEGORY
            JOIN PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.student on NAME_MASTER.ID_NUM = PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.student.alternate_id
            JOIN PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.funds on  PF_FUND_CDE_MSTR.FUND_CDE = PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.funds.fund_ledger_number
            JOIN PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.stu_award_year on PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.student.student_token = PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.stu_award_year.student_token
            JOIN PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.stu_award on PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.stu_award_year.stu_award_year_token = PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.stu_award.stu_award_year_token
            JOIN YEAR_TERM_TABLE on (YEAR_TERM_TABLE.YR_CDE = EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.YR_CDE) and (YEAR_TERM_TABLE.TRM_CDE = EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.TRM_CDE)

            Where EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.YR_CDE = '2021'
            and EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.TRM_CDE = 'FA'
            and YEAR_TERM_TABLE.TRM_BEGIN_DTE = PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.stu_award.award_period_begin_dt
            and EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AWARD_AMT = PowerFAIDS_Production.dbo.stu_award.actual_amt
            and stu_award.status = 'A'
        ),

    AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS as

        (Select distinct NAME_MASTER.ID_NUM, (NAME_MASTER.FIRST_NAME + ' ' + NAME_MASTER.LAST_NAME) as STUDENT_NAME, 
                SCHOLARSHIP.DESCRIPTION,
                Format (EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AWARD_AMT, 'C','en-us') as AWARD_AMT, 
                EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.COMMENTS,
                YR_DESC, TRM_DESC, EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AID_ELEMENT,
                (CAST (NAME_MASTER.ID_NUM as VARCHAR) + CAST (EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AID_ELEMENT as VARCHAR) ) as CHECK_ID,
                NAME_MASTER.LAST_NAME, NAME_MASTER.FIRST_NAME
        
        From NAME_MASTER
            JOIN EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS on NAME_MASTER.ID_NUM = EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.ID_NUM
            JOIN SCHOLARSHIP on EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AID_ELEMENT = SCHOLARSHIP.AID_ELEMENT
            JOIN YEAR_DEF on EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.YR_CDE = YEAR_DEF.YR_CDE
            JOIN TERM_DEF on EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.TRM_CDE = TERM_DEF.TRM_CDE
            Where EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.TRM_CDE = 'FA'
            and EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.YR_CDE = '2021'
            and EX_SCHOLARSHIP_RECIPIENTS.AID_ELEMENT not between '5000' and '5999'
    )

    Select distinct AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.ID_NUM, STUDENT_NAME,
            AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.DESCRIPTION, AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.AWARD_AMT, 
            
                --CASE
                --  WHEN AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.CHECK_ID not in (Select CHECK_ID from POWERFAIDS_CHECK)
                --  THEN 'No'
                --  ELSE 'Yes'
                --END as Processed_FA_Award,
                
                AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.COMMENTS,
            AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.YR_DESC, AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.TRM_DESC, AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.LAST_NAME, AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.FIRST_NAME
    From AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS
    LEFT OUTER JOIN POWERFAIDS_CHECK on AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.ID_NUM = POWERFAIDS_CHECK.ID_NUM
    Where AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.ID_NUM in (Select ID_NUM from AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS)

    Order by AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.DESCRIPTION, LAST_NAME, FIRST_NAME

非常感谢任何见解,谢谢!

【问题讨论】:

  • Bad Habits to Kick : Declaring VARCHAR without (length)。还要养成给你的对象别名的习惯,它会让你的查询更简洁,因此更易读。
  • 需要所有这些DISTINCTs 吗?该运算符非常昂贵,通常如果您在上述查询中需要它,则表明您的 JOINs 可能没有错。
  • 当您离开连接到 POWERFAIDS_CHECK 同时还在子查询中使用该表时,似乎有些错误。奇怪的是,您将不同的列用于看似相同的“连接”。架构问题通常会导致查询性能不佳。
  • 如果您对 CHECK_ID 的计算涉及数字,您的代码可能会产生误导性信息。将元组 和 都转换为 '112'。

标签: sql-server tsql case common-table-expression


【解决方案1】:

如果不知道您的数据和索引是什么样的,很难在这里给出明确的答案。如果您可以共享两个版本的查询的执行计划,那么给您一个明确的答案会更容易。

你可以在这里分享你的执行计划:https://www.brentozar.com/pastetheplan/

如果没有执行计划,这里有几个想法可以尝试:

  1. EXISTS 的表现通常优于 IN/NOT IN

CASE WHEN EXISTS (SELECT * FROM POWERFAIDS_CHECK WHERE CHECK_ID = AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.CHECK_ID) THEN [...]

  1. 添加包含您需要的数据子集的新 CTE 可能会有所帮助:

), VALID_CHECK_IDS AS ( SELECT DISTINCT CHECK_ID FROM POWER_FAIDS_CHECK )

然后在你的案例陈述中使用这个 CTE。

  1. 向 POWERFAIDS_CHECK 添加第二个联接

LEFT JOIN POWERFAIDS_CHECK AS VALIDCHECKID ON AWARDED_SCHOLARSHIPS.CHECK_ID = POWERFAIDS_CHECK.CHECK_ID

并将您的案例更新为

CASE WHEN VALIDCHECKID.CHECK_ID IS NOT NULL THEN 'No' ELSE 'Yes' [...]

【讨论】:

    猜你喜欢
    • 1970-01-01
    • 1970-01-01
    • 2017-05-04
    • 2017-07-13
    • 2015-07-16
    • 2023-02-01
    • 2014-03-27
    • 2020-04-04
    • 1970-01-01
    相关资源
    最近更新 更多