编辑:运行时间比较
我的原始答案(见下文)不是一个好的答案,但我认为通过对其他答案进行一些运行时分析,我做出了有用的贡献,因此我编辑了该部分并将其放在顶部.在这里,我包括了其他三个解决方案,以及产生所需输出所需的转换。为了完整起见,我还包括一个使用pandas 的版本,它假定用户正在使用DataFrame(从字典列表转换为数据框并返回甚至不值得)。比较时间根据生成的随机数据略有不同,但这些比较具有代表性:
>>> run_timer(100)
Times with 100 values
...with defaultdict: 0.1496697600000516
...with namedtuple: 0.14976404899994122
...with groupby: 0.0690777249999428
...with pandas: 3.3165711250001095
>>> run_timer(1000)
Times with 1000 values
...with defaultdict: 1.267153091999944
...with namedtuple: 0.9605341750000207
...with groupby: 0.6634409229998255
...with pandas: 3.5146895360001054
>>> run_timer(10000)
Times with 10000 values
...with defaultdict: 9.194478484000001
...with namedtuple: 9.157486462000179
...with groupby: 5.18553969300001
...with pandas: 4.704001281000046
>>> run_timer(100000)
Times with 100000 values
...with defaultdict: 59.644778522000024
...with namedtuple: 89.26688319799996
...with groupby: 93.3517027989999
...with pandas: 14.495209061999958
外卖:
-
使用 pandas 数据框可以为大型数据集节省大量时间
- 注意:我确实不包括字典列表和数据框之间的转换,这绝对是重要的
否则,可接受的解决方案(二战)在中小型数据集上胜出,但对于非常大的数据集,它可能是最慢的
更改组的大小(例如,通过减少区域的数量)会产生巨大的影响,此处未进行检查
这是我用来生成上述内容的脚本。
import random
import pandas
from timeit import timeit
from functools import partial
from itertools import groupby
from operator import itemgetter
from collections import namedtuple, defaultdict
def with_pandas(df):
return df.groupby(['zone', 'weekday', 'hour']).agg(sum).reset_index()
def with_groupby(data):
keys = itemgetter('zone', 'weekday', 'hour')
# data is your list of dicts
data.sort(key=keys)
grouped = groupby(data, keys)
new_data = []
for (zone, weekday, hour), g in grouped:
c1, c2 = 0, 0
for d in g:
c1 += d['C1']
c2 += d['C2']
new_data.append({'zone': zone, 'weekday': weekday,
'hour': hour, 'C1': c1, 'C2': c2})
return new_data
def with_namedtuple(zones):
ZoneTime = namedtuple("ZoneTime", ["zone", "weekday", "hour"])
results = dict()
for zone in zones:
zone_time = ZoneTime(zone['zone'], zone['weekday'], zone['hour'])
if zone_time in results:
results[zone_time]['C1'] += zone['C1']
results[zone_time]['C2'] += zone['C2']
else:
results[zone_time] = {'C1': zone['C1'], 'C2': zone['C2']}
return [
{
'zone': key[0],
'weekday': key[1],
'hour': key[2],
**val
}
for key, val in results.items()
]
def with_defaultdict(dictionaries):
res = defaultdict(lambda: defaultdict(int))
for d in dictionaries:
res[(d['zone'], d['weekday'], d['hour'])]['C1'] += d['C1']
res[(d['zone'], d['weekday'], d['hour'])]['C2'] += d['C2']
return [
{
'zone': key[0],
'weekday': key[1],
'hour': key[2],
**val
}
for key, val in res.items()
]
def gen_random_vals(num):
return [
{
'zone': random.choice('ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ'),
'weekday': random.randint(1, 7),
'hour': random.randint(0, 23),
'C1': random.randint(1, 50),
'C2': random.randint(1, 50),
}
for idx in range(num)
]
def run_timer(num_vals=1000, timeit_num=1000):
vals = gen_random_vals(num_vals)
df = pandas.DataFrame(vals)
p_fmt = "\t...with %s: %s"
times = {
'defaultdict': timeit(stmt=partial(with_defaultdict, vals), number=timeit_num),
'namedtuple': timeit(stmt=partial(with_namedtuple, vals), number=timeit_num),
'groupby': timeit(stmt=partial(with_groupby, vals), number=timeit_num),
'pandas': timeit(stmt=partial(with_pandas, df), number=timeit_num),
}
print("Times with %d values" % num_vals)
for key, val in times.items():
print(p_fmt % (key, val))
在哪里
原答案:
只是为了好玩,这是使用groupby 的完全不同的方法。当然,这不是最漂亮的,但应该很快。
from itertools import groupby
from operator import itemgetter
from pprint import pprint
vals = [
{'zone': 'A', 'weekday': 1, 'hour': 12, 'C1': 3, 'C2': 15},
{'zone': 'B', 'weekday': 2, 'hour': 6, 'C1': 5, 'C2': 27},
{'zone': 'A', 'weekday': 1, 'hour': 12, 'C1': 7, 'C2': 12},
{'zone': 'C', 'weekday': 5, 'hour': 8, 'C1': 2, 'C2': 13}
]
ordered = sorted(
[
(
(row['zone'], row['weekday'], row['hour']),
row['C1'], row['C2']
)
for row in vals
]
)
def invert_columns(grp):
return zip(*[g_row[1:] for g_row in grp])
merged = [
{
'zone': key[0],
'weekday': key[1],
'hour': key[2],
**dict(
zip(["C1", "C2"], [sum(col) for col in invert_columns(grp)])
)
}
for key, grp in groupby(ordered, itemgetter(0))
]
pprint(merged)
产生
[{'C1': 10, 'C2': 27, 'hour': 12, 'weekday': 1, 'zone': 'A'},
{'C1': 5, 'C2': 27, 'hour': 6, 'weekday': 2, 'zone': 'B'},
{'C1': 2, 'C2': 13, 'hour': 8, 'weekday': 5, 'zone': 'C'}]