【发布时间】:2019-03-07 16:50:58
【问题描述】:
我想在 Dafny 中编写以下函数,它使用来自 m2 的所有映射更新映射 m1,这样 m2 会覆盖 m1:
function update_map<K, V>(m1: map<K, V>, m2: map<K, V>): map<K, V>
ensures
(forall k :: k in m2 ==> update_map(m1, m2)[k] == m2[k]) &&
(forall k :: !(k in m2) && k in m1 ==> update_map(m1, m2)[k] == m1[k]) &&
(forall k :: !(k in m2) && !(k in m1) ==> !(k in update_map(m1, m2)))
{
map k | (k in m1 || k in m2) :: if k in m2 then m2[k] else m1[k]
}
我收到以下错误:
Dafny 2.2.0.10923
stdin.dfy(7,2): Error: a map comprehension involved in a function definition is not allowed to depend on the set of allocated references; Dafny's heuristics can't figure out a bound for the values of 'k' (perhaps declare its type, 'K', as 'K(!new)')
stdin.dfy(7,2): Error: a map comprehension must produce a finite set, but Dafny's heuristics can't figure out how to produce a bounded set of values for 'k'
2 resolution/type errors detected in stdin.dfy
我不明白第一个错误,对于第二个错误,如果 m1 和 m2 都有有限域,那么它们的并集当然也是有限的,但是我该如何向 Dafny 解释呢?
更新:
应用 James 的修复后,它可以工作了:
function update_map<K(!new), V>(m1: map<K, V>, m2: map<K, V>): map<K, V>
ensures
(forall k :: k in m1 || k in m2 ==> k in update_map(m1, m2)) &&
(forall k :: k in m2 ==> update_map(m1, m2)[k] == m2[k]) &&
(forall k :: !(k in m2) && k in m1 ==> update_map(m1, m2)[k] == m1[k]) &&
(forall k :: !(k in m2) && !(k in m1) ==> !(k in update_map(m1, m2)))
{
map k | k in (m1.Keys + m2.Keys) :: if k in m2 then m2[k] else m1[k]
}
【问题讨论】:
标签: dafny