【问题标题】:"Variable" variables in JavaScript\"Variable\" variables in JavaScript
【发布时间】:2021-05-19 05:19:20
【问题描述】:

I know it's possible in PHP to have "variable" variables. For example,

$x = "variable";
$$x = "Hello, World!";
echo $variable; // Displays "Hello, World!"

Is it possible to refer to a variable by its name as a string in JavaScript? How would it be done?

【问题讨论】:

  • arrays are not variables, if you use an array as a function argument , the JS interpreter will use a pointer to your array. In programming the use of certain terms is precise, and what you ask for has only very little meaning

标签: javascript variables variable-variables


【解决方案1】:

tl;dr: Don't use eval!

There is no single solution for this. It is possible to accesssomeglobal variables dynamically via window, but that doesn't work for variables local to a function. Global variables thatdo notbecome a property of window are variables defined with let and const, and classes.

There is almost always a better solution than using variable variables!Instead you should be looking at data structures and choose the right one for your problem.

If you have a fixed set of names, such as

// BAD - DON'T DO THIS!!!
var foo = 42;
var bar = 21;

var key = 'foo';
console.log(eval(key));

store the those name/values as properties of anobjectand usebracket notationto look them up dynamically:

// GOOD
var obj = {
  foo: 42,
  bar: 21,
};

var key = 'foo';
console.log(obj[key]);

InES2015+it's even easier to do this for existing variables usingconcise property notation:

// GOOD
var foo = 42;
var bar = 21;
var obj = {foo, bar};

var key = 'foo';
console.log(obj[key]);

If you have "consecutively" numbered variables, such as

// BAD - DON'T DO THIS!!!
var foo1 = 'foo';
var foo2 = 'bar';
var foo3 = 'baz';

var index = 1;
console.log(eval('foo' + index));

then you should be using anarrayinstead and simply use the index to access the corresponding value:

// GOOD
var foos = ['foo', 'bar', 'baz'];
var index = 1;
console.log(foos[index - 1]);

【讨论】:

  • In 2021 eval has become useless in this regard; at least in real world applications. Even if your CSP allows eval, I don't know any production code that ain't run through some minifier which will mess up your variable names.
  • eval is not just useless, but it has been disabled when running in strict mode. Many frameworks have the strict mode enabled by default, so I hope that we will see it disappearing :)
  • @CristianTraìna: Where did you read that eval is disabled in strict mode? It's not.
【解决方案2】:

If you are desperate to do this you can either try using eval():

var data = "testVariable";
eval("var temp_" + data + "=123;");
alert(temp_testVariable);

Or using the window object:

var data = "testVariable";
window["temp_" + data] = 123;
alert(window["temp_" + data]);

【讨论】:

  • eval can't create local variables in strict mode. An indirect call can create global variables, though.
【解决方案3】:

To reference a variable in JavaScript with only a string, you can use

window['your_variable_name']

You can set and reference variables, and objects in variables too.

【讨论】:

  • Almost always, better to namespace it into an object than attach all your variables globally on the window. Why? Scoping helps contain bugs, avoids name clashes and makes code easier to understand.
【解决方案4】:

Unlike PHP, JavaScript doesn't offer access to the globals array (which contains references to all the variable names currently declared). As such, JavaScript does not offer native support for variable variables. You can, however, emulate this feature as long as you define all your variables as part of an array or an object. This will in turn create a globals array for you. For example, instead of declaring the variable hello in the global scope like this:

var hello = 'Hello, World!';

Let's encapsulate it inside an object. We'll call that object vv (variable variables):

var vv = {
    'hello': 'Hello, World! ',
    //Other variable variables come here.
},
referToHello = 'hello';

Now we can refer to the variable by its index, and since array indexes can be provided using a variable, we are de facto making use of a variable variable:

console.log(vv[referToHello]); //Output: Hello, World!

The Answer To Your Question

Let's apply this to the code you supplied in the original question:

    var vv = {
        'x': 'variable',
        'variable': 'Hello, World!'
    };
    console.log(vv[vv['x']]); // Displays "Hello, World!"

A Practical Use

While the previous code might appear ridiculously cumbersome and impractical, there are practical uses for variable variables in JavaScript using this type of encapsulation. In the example below we use the same concept to get the ID of an undefined number of HTML elements.

var elementIds = [],
        elements = ['message','fillOrStroke','sizePicker','colorPicker']; //The items in this array could be defined automatically via an input, database query, event, etc.
        elements.forEach( (element) => {
            elementIds[element] = document.getElementById(element);
        });

This example declares variable variables (keys in elementIds) based on the ID of each element, and will assign the node of said element as the value of each variable. And since using global variables in JavaScript is generally discouraged giving your variable variables a unique scope (in this instance, declaring them inside the elementIds array) is not only neat, but also more responsible.

【讨论】:

    【解决方案5】:
    var vars = {};
    var var_name = "str";
    vars[var_name] = "working";
    console.log(vars["str"]);
    

    【讨论】:

      【解决方案6】:

      Of course you can, but don't. The variables have to be global.

      var killingFunction = 'alert'
      var killMeNow = 'please'
      var please = 'You have been killed!'
      this[killingFunction](this[killMeNow])

      【讨论】:

        【解决方案7】:

        You can use theglobalwindow object, or this:

        window:

        var data = "anyVariableName";
        window["temp_" + data] = 123;
        alert(window["temp_" + data]); //123
        

        Or using dot:

        var data = "anyVariableName";
        window.data = 123;
        alert(window.data); //123
        

        This:

        ar data = "anyVariableName";
        this["temp_" + data] = 123;
        alert(this["temp_" + data]); //123
        

        or using dot

        var data = "anyVariableName";
        this.data = 123;
        alert(this.data); //123
        

        A real-life example:

        var tasksTableNameRandom = 'tasksTable_' + Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 5);
        console.log('Tasks Table Object name: ' + tasksTableNameRandom);
        this.tasksTableNameRandom = $('#tasks-data-table').DataTable({
            ...
        });
        

        【讨论】:

        • But only if it runs in a web browser(?). What about Node.js?
        • @PeterMortensen In nodeJs there is the global variable
        【解决方案8】:

        You can use the JavaScript eval(str) function.

        This function converts the string provided into JavaScript code, and then executes it.

        For example:

        eval("console.log('Hello, World!')"); // Logs hello world
        

        So to use it as a variable variable, you can do the following:

        var a = "Hello,";
        var hello = "World!";
        console.log(a + " " + eval(a)); // Logs hello world
        

        This will produce the exact same output as:

        console.log(a + " " + hello); // Logs hello world
        

        (Example is taken from the PHP manual on variable variables.)

        【讨论】:

          猜你喜欢
          • 2019-06-04
          • 2022-12-28
          • 2022-12-02
          • 2017-04-12
          • 2016-12-22
          • 2022-12-02
          • 2022-12-27
          • 2022-12-02
          • 2022-12-27
          相关资源
          最近更新 更多